In the world of heavy metal, Metallica's 1998 release, Garage Inc, was a bold and unexpected move. But here's where it gets controversial – the album opens with a grinding dirge by Discharge, a punk band from the 80s. This choice, while daring, sparked a mini-industry of Discharge covers in the 90s among metal bands like Anthrax and Machine Head. And this is the part most people miss – Metallica's version stayed faithful to the original, but with a twist.
'Free Speech for the Dumb'
Discharge, known for their brutal and basic noise assaults, laid the foundation for metallic hardcore. Metallica's cover of 'Free Speech for the Dumb' from Discharge's 1982 debut, showcases their respect for the pioneers while adding a metallic grind. Guitarist Tony 'Bones' Roberts admits that capturing the original sound is a challenge, making Metallica's rendition even more impressive.
'It's Electric' by Diamond Head
Diamond Head, part of the New Wave of British Heavy Metal, inspired a young Lars Ulrich. Their song 'It's Electric' caught Metallica's attention, and they covered it after hearing a rehearsal room cassette. Guitarist Brian Tatler recalls the song's special place in their live set, despite limited gigs at the time. Metallica's early setlists even included Diamond Head songs, a testament to their influence.
Black Sabbath's 'Sabbra Cadabra'
Metallica's cover of 'Sabbra Cadabra' holds a special place in then-bassist Jason Newsted's heart, as Geezer Butler is his favorite bassist. The song, from Sabbath's fifth album, is a cheerful rock'n'roll tune. Metallica considered combining it with another Sabbath song, 'A National Acrobat,' but ultimately kept it separate.
Bob Seger's 'Turn the Page' – A Controversial Choice?
Metallica's cover of Bob Seger's 'Turn the Page' is an emotional ballad that perfectly suits the band. However, it's a controversial choice, as Kirk admitted he wasn't a big Seger fan. The song's inclusion showcases Metallica's ability to make unexpected selections work.
'Die, Die My Darling' by Misfits
Cliff Burton introduced Metallica to Misfits, and their cover of 'Die, Die My Darling' is a testament to that influence. The song, originally recorded in 1981, is incredibly catchy and has remained a fan favorite.
Nick Cave & The Bad Seeds' 'Loverman' – An Unlikely Addition
Amidst 70s rock and 80s metal covers, Metallica included Nick Cave & The Bad Seeds' 'Loverman,' an alternative epic of obsessive lust. James Hetfield's choice was quirky, but he believed Metallica could do it justice. The song was recorded late at night, capturing the perfect mood.
Mercyful Fate Medley – A Tribute to Contemporaries
Mercyful Fate, contemporaries of Metallica in the 80s extreme metal scene, received a magnificent tribute on Garage Inc. Metallica carefully arranged segments of five songs to create a labor of love. Frontman King Diamond was thrilled to hear the medley, praising Metallica's amazing take on their songs.
Blue Öyster Cult's 'Astronomy' – A Sensitivity in Metal
Blue Öyster Cult, promoted as the American Sabbath, showcased their sensitive side with 'Astronomy.' The song's co-writer, Joe Bouchard, was inspired to return to music after hearing Metallica's cover. The success of the album, selling 5 million copies, further highlights the impact of Metallica's interpretations.
'Whiskey in the Jar' – A Traditional Irish Ballad
Metallica's cover of 'Whiskey in the Jar' is a traditional Irish folk ballad dating back to the 17th century. The band drew inspiration from Thin Lizzy's 1972 version, and all four members were fans of the Dublin rockers. The cover's success led to a Grammy win, accompanied by a wild video.
Lynyrd Skynyrd's 'Tuesday's Gone' – A Southern Rock Classic
Metallica's cover of Lynyrd Skynyrd's 'Tuesday's Gone' is a moving ballad from the founding fathers of Southern rock. James Hetfield's connection to Skynyrd is evident, as he revealed that 'Sweet Home Alabama' was his first vinyl purchase. The cover was first performed at an all-acoustic benefit organized by Neil Young.
'The More I See' by Discharge – Bookending the Album
Garage Inc. begins and ends with Discharge songs, with 'The More I See' closing the album. The song, a 1984 single, showcases Discharge's shift towards a more metal sound. The band members met Metallica at various venues, and while they didn't get a free t-shirt, they were honored by the cover.
This album, Garage Inc, is a testament to Metallica's ability to surprise and pay homage to their influences. From punk to metal, they've left their mark on the heavy metal landscape. What do you think of Metallica's daring choices and their impact on the genre? Share your thoughts and keep the conversation going!
